Are we laggards in technology adoption?

Posted on 24 April 2012

By Mike Killalea, editor & publisher

We pride ourselves on innovation, but are actually laggards at technology adoption.

“The oil and gas industry tends to have a technology adoption cycle of roughly 30 years from concept to 50% market penetration,” remarked Dustin Torkay, Seadrill, IADC Advanced Rig Technology (ART) Committee vice chairman-Future Technology, adding that this is an eight-year process in the medical industry. Mr Torkay is the driving force behind our 12 June ART Workshop on technology adoption. The afternoon workshop will convene in Barcelona the day before IADC World Drilling 2012.

Tom Bates, Lime Rock Partners, an ART workshop panelist, agrees that the pace of technology adoption is “painfully slow.” Mr Bates should know. His long career prior to joining investment firm Lime Rock as a managing director began with Shell and includes leadership positions at Baker Hughes, Weatherford Enterra and Schlumberger.

“There is almost an order of magnitude difference from other industries,” he said. “It’s a bit of a conundrum, (because) overall, our industry is not risk averse.”

Stagnation Generation

One case in point is stagnation in directional MWD, which, according to sponsors of a new Drilling Engineering Association joint industry project (JIP), has not appreciably advanced in a generation.

Now, before MWD partisans rouse to churn out indignant emails championing their companies’ achievements, let me stress that MWD overall has seen many advances. But, according to the DEA JIP sponsors, the process for directional MWD has barely budged in 30 years.

“The perception is that it’s good enough, because we are able to get to the production target,” said Robert Estes, Baker Hughes, which, along with ConocoPhillips and Bench Tree Group, are current sponsors.

The need for more precise directional MWD is pressing, Mr Estes says. A next-generation MWD tool drilling a relief well could reduce time to intersection and enhance accuracy. For infill drilling amid a spider’s web of directional wells, avoiding collision through pinpoint placement might prevent a blowout. For steam-assisted gravity-drainage wells, more precision can maximize production by optimizing well placement.

The organizers are seeking another seven or so JIP participants, at about $30,000 each. (Click here for more on the JIP.)

Dragging Innovation

The question remains. Why does innovation drag? ART workshop participant Jan Brakel, manager for wells R&D with Shell, suspects that with activity booming, the status quo suits most. “Is there a need to innovate?” he asks, though he himself is a strong proponent of change.

He points out that, rig newbuilding notwithstanding, a plethora of ancient equipment still keeps turning to the right.

“In general, as a drilling industry we have a significant catch-up opportunity in terms of technology,” Mr Brakel said.

Business Units Limit Vision

Mr Bates suggests that innovation began to flag when major oil companies switched to the business unit model.

“Business units are great for giving objectives and giving senior manager accountability for results,” he said.

On the other hand, a business-unit leader’s focus on that narrow bottom line is hardly an incentive to try something new, expensive and with potentially large downside risk.

Independents harbor a more entrepreneurial spirit, Mr Bates noted.

“It wasn’t a supermajor that developed the Barnett, with 25 frac jobs and 15,000-ft laterals,” he pointed out.

A corollary of narrowed vision is a dearth of test sites, he added.

“One of the frustrating things for me,” Mr Bates said, “is the inability to get products in the field and tested. That is a real barrier to progress.”

Mr Bates urges industry to develop a cooperative means to test promising technologies without jeopardizing wells, thereby helping to move technology forward.

“At the end of the day, technology works.”

Mike Killalea can be reached via email at mike.killalea@iadc.org.

Leave a Reply

*

FEATURED MICROSITES


Recent Drilling News

  • 17 December 2014

    Saudi Aramco: Four factors for a sustainable drilling business

    Despite the modest growth in demand and drop in oil prices today, the long-term outlook for industry is healthy. “Our industry will need to add around 40 million bbl per day for new capacity...

  • 16 December 2014

    Ensco development program produces driller in 3 years

    Ensco’s Accelerated Development Program (ADP) takes a “green” individual and, within a three-year period, trains them to become a driller. In response to personnel shortages in various areas, including drilling...

  • 16 December 2014

    Saudi Aramco: ‘Industry cannot afford to lose talent when the economy is down’

    Industry is facing a human resources challenge in two areas: the ageing workforce and the shortage of skills, Mohammed Al Sellemi...

  • 16 December 2014

    Nanotechnology has potential to improve tool performance in extreme environments

    In terms of temperature stability and corrosion, tools have limitations, especially in extremely challenging drilling environments. Jothibasu Ramasamy...

  • 16 December 2014

    Colville: WCI provides forum to evaluate practical, economical advances in well control practices

    Major players throughout industry are joining forces under the Well Control Institute (WCI). The mandate of WCI is “to provide the definitive forum...

  • Read more news