CATEGORIZED | 2014, Drilling It Safely, May/June

HSE&T Corner: Alliance governance can help manage risk in contractor/service company interface

Posted on 22 April 2014

By Linda Hsieh, managing editor, and Lauren Wolfson, editorial assistant

Robyn Stephens, Principal Consultant at Atkins, spoke at the 2014 IADC HSET Conference about how the concept of alliance governance can be applied to overcome the challenges of HSE management in the field.

Robyn Stephens, Principal Consultant at Atkins, spoke at the 2014 IADC HSET Conference about how the concept of alliance governance can be applied to overcome the challenges of HSE management in the field.

On any drilling rig, the relationships among operators, drilling contractors and various service companies can be complex, leading to obstacles in the management of HSE and process safety risks. In such cases, the concept of alliance governance can help, Robyn Stephens, Principal Consultant at Atkins, explained in a presentation at the 2014 IADC Health, Safety, Environment & Training Conference in February.

The relationship that an operator has, each with the drilling contractor and with the service contractor, is contractual. It is based on legally binding documents that provide clear expectations and boundaries under which both parties operate. However, there is often no legally binding document guiding the relationship between the drilling contractor and the service company.

“There’s no contract between these entities. The service contractor is expected to perform services under the authority of the operator. However, by being on the drilling rig, the service contractor is expected to follow the requirements if their host is to perform the work. This implies the relationship between the drilling contractor and the service contractor is basically influential,” Mr Stephens said.

He noted that the amount of authoritative weight that each has over the other is limited, however, compared with an actual contractual relationship. “Yet, the drilling contractor is often expected by the operator to set the requirements on the service contractor with regards to numerous safe work practices and elements of integrity management programs,” he said. This all results in inconsistent accountability and authority.

Mr Stephens highlighted an example with the common expectation for drilling contractors to inspect and test safety-critical equipment for integrity management plans and reporting that to the operator. “Yet, they have no authority over the cement unit, which is often safety-critical equipment, and cannot assure that inspections and tests are occurring when they should really have no authority to assure that those tests are performed properly.” This type of situation ultimately can lead to false assurance that risks are being properly managed, he said.

Under the concept of alliance governance, the drilling contractor/service company relationship can be clarified. The alliance governance model is based on two risks: the performance risk and the relationship risk. For this industry, performance risk can be assumed to be high, particularly as it pertains to HSE and process safety. The relationship risk can be high or low depending on whether there is established trust between the two parties.

Where there is a high level of trust between the two entities, Mr Stephens said, control can be established through simple mechanisms, such as an alliance charter that speaks to the common understanding and commitment. “A good example is simple nondisclosure agreements that describe the duty shared, the performance risks and the desired targets.”

Mr Stephens added that, even in such situations, “it needs to be recognized there is a first among equals, and of course, that’s the drilling contractor. After all, it’s their rig.”

Where there is a low level of trust, he continued, “then the drilling contractor may want to look at the use of more formal and rigorous documents – a more detailed MOU or even some form of contractual agreement.”

It should incorporate many levels of communication at various layers to specifically define who’s to speak on what when issues are raised, he said. “Monitoring and verification often then become requirements within these sort of documents on governance.”

Mr Stephens explained that it is necessary that such alliance governance mechanisms be created to be fit for purpose. “A one-size-fits-all standard for alliance governance is extremely ineffective and possibly could even exacerbate problems.” As unique alliances are formed and both entities begin to trust each other, success becomes easier to attain. “Trust is built on a foundation that both partners are intrinsically motivated to make an alliance successful.”

Click here for more articles about health, safety, environment and training can be found at DC’s Drilling It Safely microsite.

Leave a Reply

*

FEATURED MICROSITES


Recent Drilling News

  • 20 October 2014

    Ocean Rig awarded extensions for ultra-deepwater drillships in Brazil

    Ocean Rig has been awarded extensions for its two ultra-deepwater drillships, the Ocean Rig Corcovado and the Ocean Rig Mykonos by Petrobras for drilling offshore Brazil…

  • 16 October 2014

    BG Group appoints Helge Lund as CEO; Statoil appoints Eldar Sætre as acting President and CEO

    "It has been a privilege to lead Statoil during 10 very exciting years,” Mr Lund said. “Together we have created values for Statoil’s shareholders and the society…

  • 15 October 2014

    Eni signs two PSCs for offshore exploration in Vietnam

    Eni has signed two production-sharing contracts (PSCs) with Petrovietnam for the exploration of blocks 116 and 124, located off the coast of Vietnam…

  • 13 October 2014

    OneSubsea awarded contract for PEMEX Lakach deepwater development

    OneSubsea, a Cameron and Schlumberger company, has been awarded a subsea production systems contract totaling more than $270 million for the Lakach deepwater project…

  • 08 October 2014

    Shell starts oil production from Gumusut-Kakap deepwater platform in Malaysia

    Shell has started oil production from the Gumusut-Kakap floating platform off the coast of Malaysia, the latest in a series of Shell deepwater projects...

  • Read more news