CATEGORIZED | News

Mud transfer may be gap in contingency planning

Posted on 10 May 2011

A kill operation may require 5,000 to 10,000 bbl or more of mud that has to be stored and transferred to the high-pressure pumps. “It could become quite complicated in an offshore operation,” John Wright of John Wright Company said on 2 May at OTC in Houston.

A kill operation may require 5,000 to 10,000 bbl or more of mud that has to be stored and transferred to the high-pressure pumps. “It could become quite complicated in an offshore operation,” John Wright of John Wright Company said on 2 May at OTC in Houston.

“Hope is not a strategy, particularly in this post-Macondo world,” John Wright, president and blowout engineering advisor for John Wright Company, said at the Offshore Technology Conference in Houston on 2 May, kicking off his presentation on the drilling of relief wells and how to deal with uncertainty. He believes that one of the biggest gaps in companies’ blowout contingency plans actually lies with the transfer of mud to high-pressure pumps.

After the Macondo blowout, the BJ Services Blue Dolphin ultra-deepwater stimulation vessel was used to aid the drilling of relief wells. The vessel features 23,000 hydraulic horsepower and 20,000-psi pumps, and its umbilical lines have a maximum pump rate of 80 bbl/min. “We were very fortunate to have such a vessel in the Gulf of Mexico … but in other places of the world, you may not have this,” Mr Wright said.

When performing hydraulic modeling for contingency plans, it’s one thing to determine that you need 15,000 hydraulic horsepower and 10,000 bbl of mud for the kill operation. “But where are you going to store that mud? Where will the vessel come from?” he asked. Other questions to consider include: How are you going to transfer it from the mud supply vessel to the frac boat, if you plan on using frac boats? Do frac boats in your region have both the capacity for flow rate as well as the hydraulic horsepower for pressure?

“You might be able to store 10,000 bbl of mud in the below-deck tanks, but you’re not going to be able to transfer that mud up to those high-pressure tanks at any kind of rate,” Mr Wright said. “Even the large fifth-generation floaters that have 10,000-bbl mud capacities, in a lot of cases I’ve found that you just cannot transfer mud from those pits at high enough flow rates even though the mud pumps might have the hydraulic horsepower capacity to pump it.”

Mr Wright also stressed the importance of doing hydraulic simulations for flow diagnostics and hydraulic kill design. “In my opinion, this is the most important thing that you will do in any blowout scenario, the contingency planning scenario. It drives all control strategies,” he said. For example, hydraulic simulations define what the flow problem is – what are the boundary conditions. “Particularly in a relief well scenario, you really don’t know what the flow patterns are, so you’ve got to go through and look at various potential situations and model those situations and see if that looks anything like what you’re observing.” After ranking those scenarios, the kill is then planned around the most likely scenario.

Hydraulic simulations also define the best option for the relief well – whether you can bullhead and stay under certain pressures, or if you can snub the pipe to bottom. It also defines requirements for support equipment, rig equipment and kill equipment. “What kind of kill fluids should you have? You cannot kill with fluids that are higher than the fracture gradient. If you’ve got a good dynamic simulator, you can assess those various options,” Mr Wright said.

1 Comments For This Post

  1. Randy Ruedrich Says:

    Excellent technical analysis of real questions that need to be answered in the contingency planning for any well.

Leave a Reply

*

FEATURED MICROSITES


Recent Drilling News

  • 22 October 2014

    Shell discovers gas in pre-salt reservoir offshore Gabon

    Shell announced a frontier exploration discovery offshore Gabon, West Africa. The well Leopard-1 encountered a substantial gas column with around 200 m net gas pay…

  • 22 October 2014

    Statoil proves new oil resources near Grane field in North Sea

    Well 25/8-18 S, drilled by the rig Transocean Leader, proved an oil column of 25 m in the Heimdal Formation. The estimated volume of the discovery…

  • 21 October 2014

    IADC Cybersecurity Task Group to provide industry guidance to assess risks

    The oil and gas industry is not immune to cybersecurity threats, from computer viruses and malware to targeted attacks. The IADC Advanced Rig Technology (ART) Committee…

  • 21 October 2014

    Check-6 launches RIGOR digital checklist and compliance system

    Check-6 has launched RIGOR, a checklist-based mobile app to help simplify complex procedures and mitigate human error on the rig. Taking lessons from the aviation industry…

  • 21 October 2014

    Video: Next IADC Land Contract update to start in 2016

    The latest version of the IADC Land Contract was released in November 2013. Various incidents, including Macondo, delayed the release. “It’s an industry contract…

  • Read more news