CATEGORIZED | News

Shale drilling: paradox of public perception

Posted on 22 February 2011

With the perceived negative impacts of shale drilling surfacing in urban communities, the industry should do more to present the facts at community meetings.

With the perceived negative impacts of shale drilling surfacing in urban communities, the industry should do more to present the facts at community meetings.

There is a paradox in the way the general public views the oil and gas industry, a study of two counties within the Barnett Shale found. Although the public distrusts the intrusion of the natural gas industry and dislikes certain problematic issues perceived to accompany it, the majority of citizens appreciate and welcome the economic and service-related benefits that accompany the industry. The findings were presented by Gene Theodori, professor of sociology and director of the Center for Rural Studies at Sam Houston State University, at the IADC Oil and Gas Shale Drilling Technology Workshop held in Houston on 27 January.

The public’s negative perception of the energy industry is not new. API research gathered has shown that the oil industry is ranked second only to tobacco as the industry with the worst public image. The industry’s ranking in the Gallup Poll has also remained fairly consistent for the past 10 years: It was unfailingly ranked as the least positively viewed industry in the US.

The Barnett study was undertaken because it was thought that shale drilling is a “timely and salient issue in the urban environment in need of sociological research.” Results revealed the paradox where the public viewed social and environmental issues more negatively and viewed economic and service-related issues more positively.

The top six negatively viewed issues cited were increased truck traffic, the amount of fresh water used, high tax rates, depletion of aquifers, noise pollution and water pollution. Participants in the study also saw potential threats to public health and safety, such as unsafe driving practices, gas leaks and explosions. Concerns regarding negative issues were greater among respondents in the county where energy development was more mature.

One question in the study specifically asked whether the benefits of energy development outweighed the costs. In the county where large-scale development was just beginning to occur, respondents unanimously agreed that the benefits of production would outweigh the costs. However, in the county where industry activity was more mature, respondents unanimously reported that the costs outweighed the benefits. When asked whether regional differences played a role in the public’s concern, Mr Theodori said, “The concern pattern is the same. It is the degree of perceived severity that fluctuates.”

Noting that the mass of the general public is not informed about the energy industry, Mr Theodori recommended that the industry bring multiple stakeholders to the table to work on the solution. Why should the industry attempt to influence people to understand us? “The license to operate to gain access to resources,” he said.

Leave a Reply

*

FEATURED MICROSITES


Recent Drilling News

  • 22 October 2014

    Shell discovers gas in pre-salt reservoir offshore Gabon

    Shell announced a frontier exploration discovery offshore Gabon, West Africa. The well Leopard-1 encountered a substantial gas column with around 200 m net gas pay…

  • 22 October 2014

    Statoil proves new oil resources near Grane field in North Sea

    Well 25/8-18 S, drilled by the rig Transocean Leader, proved an oil column of 25 m in the Heimdal Formation. The estimated volume of the discovery…

  • 21 October 2014

    IADC Cybersecurity Task Group to provide industry guidance to assess risks

    The oil and gas industry is not immune to cybersecurity threats, from computer viruses and malware to targeted attacks. The IADC Advanced Rig Technology (ART) Committee…

  • 21 October 2014

    Check-6 launches RIGOR digital checklist and compliance system

    Check-6 has launched RIGOR, a checklist-based mobile app to help simplify complex procedures and mitigate human error on the rig. Taking lessons from the aviation industry…

  • 21 October 2014

    Video: Next IADC Land Contract update to start in 2016

    The latest version of the IADC Land Contract was released in November 2013. Various incidents, including Macondo, delayed the release. “It’s an industry contract…

  • Read more news