CATEGORIZED | News

Stick-slip mitigation workshop results presented at Drilling Conference

Posted on 04 March 2011

“Surface monitoring systems with downhole information” was the top pick when workshop participants were asked which technology is the most effective stick-slip mitigation.

“Surface monitoring systems with downhole information” was the top pick when workshop participants were asked which technology is the most effective stick-slip mitigation.

An IADC workshop dedicated to stick-slip mitigation concluded that there is no single silver bullet among current technologies to solve the problem of stick-slip, said Tom Geehan, M-I Swaco, during a presentation at the 2011 SPE/IADC Drilling Conference on 3 March in Amsterdam. “However, all the services and control systems can offer cost-effective benefits in certain situations. And given the fact that there’s no silver bullet at this point, rig training is still required to recognize and mitigate stick-slip,” Mr Geehan said.

The July 2010 workshop, sponsored by the Future Technology Subcommittee of the IADC Advanced Rig Technology Committee, was meant to be a tutorial on stick-slip – defining it, exploring the value of mitigation and learning about different mitigation technologies. The business value of mitigation stick-slip was presented by an operator, based primarily on cost-per-unit-depth analysis. Technologies presented at the workshop ranged from basic monitoring to analysis services to soft torque control systems.

Workshop attendees were then surveyed on which mitigation approach they believe to be the most effective, and “surface monitoring systems with downhole information” ended up as the top pick. “BHA and bits” and “soft torque systems” followed. On which mitigation approach was seen as the most cost-effective, “soft torque systems” received the most number of votes, followed by “surface monitoring systems with downhole information,” then “surface monitoring systems.”

In explaining these survey results, Mr Geehan provided the caveat that 61% of the 100-plus participants at the workshop were from service companies; 11% were operators and 7% were from drilling contractors. This fact was later highlighted during the Q&A following Mr Geehan’s presentation, when a conference delegate from ExxonMobil noted that he sees bigger drill pipe as the most dominant way to stop stick-slip. Yet that was not included as an option in the workshop’s audience surveys, the delegate pointed out.

During the roundtable discussion at the workshop, several suggestions were made on possible future efforts for stick-slip mitigation. One comment said that further gains could be made if companies work with each other and try to control both rotational speed and weight rather than each alone. The inter-relationship of torsional vibration and lateral vibration was recognized; and the use of high-resolution data, such as from wired pipe, was encouraged. In fact, it was concluded that “the use of real-time downhole data to close the loop is the frontier which could result in a step-change improvement in management of the multiple modes of drillstring vibration,” Mr Geehan said.

“Obviously, an opportunity exists to develop more cost-effective solutions in this area,” he said.

As the IADC Future Technology Subcommittee’s mission is to encourage technology commercialization and increase the technology adoption rate in the industry, with a focus on high-need applications, the group welcomes recommendations for other technology workshops. More information about the Advanced Rig Technology Committee and the Future Technology Subcommittee can be found here.

More detailed results from the workshop, from SPE/IADC 140044, “Results of July 15, 2010 IADC Stick-Slip Mitigation Workshop,” will be published in the March/April 2011 issue of Drilling Contractor.

1 Comments For This Post

  1. Mike Lynch Says:

    Exactly what is stick-Slip? How do you recognize it?

Leave a Reply

*

FEATURED MICROSITES


Recent Drilling News

  • 26 January 2015

    Young professionals program at SPE/IADC Drilling Conference to target future leaders of the industry

    The oil and gas industry is constantly looking to the future. Whether this comes in the form of pushing the limits of pressure...

  • 22 January 2015

    Tullow Oil moves ahead with exploration, appraisal drilling onshore Kenya

    Tullow Oil has announced updates on several onshore projects in Kenya, including the Expir-1 exploration, Engomo-1 exploration, the Ngamia and Amosing...

  • 22 January 2015

    Petrobras reduces operating costs, time with new pre-salt subsea equipment deployment technique

    At the end of last year, Petrobras deployed its first wet Christmas tree using cables in the pre-salt area. The main change involved was the use of a subsea equipment...

  • 22 January 2015

    XACT, BP complete first deepwater deployment of SandSentry Acoustic Telemetry Network in Gulf of Mexico

    XACT Downhole Telemetry, in conjunction with BP, recently completed the first operational field trial of the SandSentry Acoustic Telemetry Network in the deepwater Gulf of Mexico...

  • 21 January 2015

    University of Houston to lead subsea engineering research center

    The University of Houston (UH) will lead a national research center for subsea engineering and other offshore energy development issues, including research and technology…

  • Read more news